Tuesday, June 16, 2009
Adequate Yearly Progress?
Adequate Yearly Progress (AYP) is a statewide accountability system mandated by the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 which requires each state to ensure that all public schools and districts meet minimal standards. The two instruments used to measure this progress are the Criterion Referenced Competency Test (CRCT) and the Georgia High School Graduation Test. A passing score on the CRCT is required for third graders in the area of reading. Fifth and eighth graders are required to receive a passing score in the areas of math and English. However, after a thorough investigation by the Atlanta Journal and Constitution it was discovered that many schools allowed a great percentage of students who failed these critical subject areas to be promoted to the next grade level despite their level of aptitude. McNair Middle School, located in Dekalb County, promoted 95.41% of 283 eighth graders who were unsuccessful in passing the CRCT. More recently four local schools have come under fire for changing answers on the CRCT. The principal of one school found to have erased up to 46 incorrect answers of 70 possible responses and replaced them with correct answers resigned amidst all of the upheaval. Why all the fuss over silly tests that may or may not determine whether a child moves forward in school? The plain and ugly truth is MONEY. When a school fails to meet AYP funding is taken away, students are allowed to attend schools outside their district, as well as sanctions are imposed to ensure the remaining students receive academic help to achieve better test results. So with so much on the line and national government policies in place to erase educational gaps, why are students the ones who are really being failed along with these state mandated tests?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Oooohhhh!! And people wonder why I elected to teach in the independent school setting!
ReplyDeleteI would not send my child to a school that does not meet AYP standards. It is unfortunate that the principle felt the need to falsify testing results. On the flip side I think that it is important to recognize that all students are not "standardized test takers". There should be other criteria to determine the advancement of a student academically.
ReplyDeleteThis is a topic I'm just becoming familiar with now that I have a child and I don't think I'll be sending her to our neighborhood school. I like that there are a lot of options when it comes to education these days; better performing public schools, charter schools, independent schools, etc. I plan to research all the options before choosing which school I send my child.
ReplyDeleteI think "adequate yearly progress" can carry many different meanings. I understand its primary technical meaning and of course I'd like to see my child progress accordingly. At the same time I teach in an environment where so many other valuable variables are at play. This is a tough call for me. Ideally I'd love for my child to make adequate or more than adequate progress each year but not at the sacrifice of his personal happiness or sense of well-being as a child.
ReplyDeleteI teach in a private school, where thankfully we are not held to the AYP assessment, but of course we are held to scrutiny when our kids take other kinds of standardized tests. Also, they must be accepted at other schools when they leave us, and their skills must be strong. This does not carry the same kind of tension with it that the NCLB laws do. I believe that tying funding to the testing is a very problematic thing, because if a school needs to do better and the funding is gone, this makes it much harder for them to do better! Nevertheless, principals and teachers must be honest. I have much empathy for schools that struggle with these testing issues, and the burdens it places on teachers, administrators, and especially, children.
ReplyDelete